Remember, during Advent, I mentioned getting an odd inspiration at 4:00am to write about asexuality, and said I might post it sometime after Advent. Well, here is it (and be warned, it is incredibly long!) …
It’s 4:00am, and I’m not tired. Having spent the last few days exhausted, unwell and in pain, today I was delighted to discover I felt better. With it came a renewed feeling of cheerfulness and good humour and renewed energy. Also renewed concentration - I could sit and read for longer. So I sat and read Ghosts by Adrian Plass. I’d bought it cheap from amazon, as I’d always quite enjoyed reading his books years ago, and felt like reading another one.
I was reminded, as I read it, that as well as being quite amusing and interesting to read, his books also invoke a kind of frusration and illogical sense of inadequacy in me. See, his books all tend to have the same running themes in them. One such theme is the importance of being real - not being some fake whitewashed thing, but to be yourself freely, with your real feelings, your real struggles, etc. With which I wholeheartedly agree, and in fact that part makes me feel quite happy, because being real is something I’m jolly good at. But then comes the next bit. Real single women have real, strong, passionate sexual feelings and fantasies. Being single and refraining from sex is a struggle. Real Christian single women are not some fake feelingless imaginary super-spiritual beings who are above sexual feelings. And if they claim they are, they are not being real.
Of course, my logic and common sense tell me that Adrian Plass probably hasn’t even heard of asexuality, and if he met me and I told him what it was, he probably would exempt me from this terrible judgement of not being real! But of course, back in my younger days, when I’d never heard of asexuality, and I assumed I must simply be repressed, I used to come away from his books with the vague feeling that I was somehow sinning for not having sexual thoughts! That I wasn’t yet good enough to be a proper ‘real’ Christian. It amuses me to look back, but still I find myself frustrated with Adrian Plass’s books. They always neatly include the single woman dealing with her sexual feelings, the gay man struggling with his feelings, and there is always a bit of a tone that suggests such topics are rather daring - but never do they include an asexual woman who wonders what a sexual feeling is and why she doesn’t have one. Never do they include a character on the autistic spectrum who, unlike the rest of Plass’s lovely ‘real’ characters. really doesn’t know all the right things to say at the right time, or when to be flippant and when to be serious, in order to prevent or rectify difficult moments.
I remember as a child I was seen as a bit of a rude ingrate with the makings of a naughty heathen at church because I never wanted the Christian children’s novels that I won as prizes for memorising scripture and attending Sunday School. I would hand them back saying ‘No thanks - I’ve read it and I don’t like it’ or ‘No, I don’t like books like this’. The reason being that then, as now, there were never any characters that I could identify with in the slightest, and the simplistic morals irritated me beyond belief. Adrian Plass does try to get beyond the simplistic morals, which is why I like his books in general, but still, I do find the list of issues he deals with to be rather narrow.
So anyway, being wide awake at what is now 4:30am, I have decided to write about what it is like to be an asexual Christian. Because I doubt anyone knows, unless they are asexual themselves, because, well, there simply aren’t any asexual Christian characters in Christian literature.
Ever since I was a tiny child, I would make up stories in my head. I would invent characters and make up stories about what happened to them. At four years old, I would tell the stories out loud to the many imaginary friends who lived in my bedroom (everything in my bedroom was my friend - I would say ‘Hi lightswitch’ and ‘Hi wallpaper’ and give them a kiss, truly believing they were my friends). As I grew older, I started to tell the stories in my head.
Now, it always irked me that my younger sisters didn’t make up such stories. I assumed they would as they grew older, but whenever I asked them about their stories, they said they didn’t have any. I would tell them to start making up stories, because it was the most wonderful thing ever, but they tried it and didn’t like it, which I couldn’t understand at all.
However, when we were teenagers, one of my sisters mentioned to me that she’d started making up stories. I was delighted for her, and asked to know what they were about. She told me they were about her and a boy, at which I told her that she was doing it all wrong, and that they should not be about her, but about imaginary characters! But she told me how great it was to think of a story about yourself and a boy, and that I should try it. I asked what sort of things she did with this boy in her stories, and I was most disappointed to find out that it was boring stuff like kissing and getting into bed together and feeling each other, etc. No real plot at all! Our other sister joined the conversation at some point and rather embarrassedly admitted that she had started making up such stories at night too.
So I tried it. I made up an elaborate story in my head about me meeting a boy and we went to the theatre to watch Les Miserables, because that was a musical I really wanted to see, and we went to a restaurant and ate macaroni cheese, because that was my favourite meal, and meringue and cream for dessert. But… well… I really didn’t want to kiss him. I wanted him to go away so that I could sit in peace and read a book! And then I decided it was a boring pointless story because I could sit and read a book in real life, and I could listen to the tape of Les Miserables on my stereo, and I could eat macaroni cheese at home, and it was much more fun to make up stories about characters who are not me.
So… er… the point of sexual fantasies completely eluded me! In fact, I had never even heard of the concept of a sexual fantasy, and I thought it was just a different sort of story that people could make up in their heads, and a bit of a stupid pointless sort for people who weren’t very good at making up proper stories.
Well, maybe that sets the scene a little for the way my mind works. At school, other girls dated boys and talked about what actors and singers they fancied. I assumed the reason I wasn’t dating because I was weird and shy (which of course would have played a part - but I didn’t seem to realise the significance of the fact that I didn’t want to date anyone. I didn’t get crushes at all. It didn’t even occur to me that dating was something most people wanted to do. I assumed it was another pointless ritual in life that people do at some point, and that one day I would do it when my acne went away and I gained a few social skills!
Now, at age 17, I went to Bible School for a year (by some administration mistake, I was put into the wrong year at the school I moved to when I was 13, and so I finished my A levels a year younger than everyone else). I remember one day at Bible School, George Verwer came to speak to us - and I was so excited, because I’d been on Love Europe and heard him speak powerfully and inspiringly about all kinds of things. I wondered if he would talk about grace - that was his big topic at Love Europe. I remember really looking forward to him speaking at Bible School, especially when he told us he was going to talk about a topic that isn’t normally talked about, but which is vital for young people and their relationship with God. Then he announed the topic was sex, and sexual feelings, and I felt myself deflate in disappointment. What an utterly boring and irrelevant topic. I had been hoping for something relevant to my life, to help me in my relationship with God, to help me get to know God better. I assumed everyone else would be as disappointed in such a silly topic as I was, but as I looked round the room I realised that actually this probably was an important topic to a lot of people in the room. And I felt like I was different from everyone else - but then I’d always felt that in many ways, so it wasn’t something I dwelt much on. I confess, I didn’t pay attention to his talk. I tried, but it really just didn’t interest me at all. And I was bitterly disappointed as I’d really been looking forward to an inspiring, life-changing talk!
I remember then having a similar experience a few years later when I was in Canada. I had joined the inter-varsity Christian fellowship there, and we had a weekend retreat at a convent. Again, I was looking forward to it so much - I really do love hearing inspiring Christian speakers who can help me understand God in new ways. It was the Saturday afternoon, I believe, that we had a speaker who told us that he was going to talk about a subject that he knew was very important to all of us, and a very difficult and emotional subject. The subject, again, was sex. He assured us that he knew that as young people we thought about this subject a lot and it meant a lot to us. Because all young people think about sex. And he wanted us to go to our rooms and spend an hour alone with God … honestly, I can’t renmember the exact details, but that is because I never quite understood them. I’m sure he didn’t actually tell us to go to our rooms and spend an hour thinking about God and sex, but that is how I interpreted it. I’m sure there were finer subtleties - like being real with God about sexual feelings, confessing sexual sins, etc. But I had no sexual sins to confess, no sexual feelings to talk to God about, so I remember sitting on my bed feeling terribly guilty that I wasn’t doing the exercise properly because I had no idea how to think about sex. I also felt rather guilty/confused (I wasn’t quite sure which emotion was appropriate) that all young people think about sex, and I was a young person, so by law of logic I must therefore think about sex - but I wasn’t aware of having done so, so somehow I must have done it without noticing it. I should have been paying attention to these sexual thoughts that I must have had because I was a young person. They had clearly come and I hadn’t noticed and now I wasn’t able to do this exercise of thinking about sex, and so I was missing this opportunity to be close to God. I remember sitting there quite desolately with this long hour gaping ahead of me, having to carry out an exercise that I didn’t understand, and on which no doubt I would have to report back to the group. What on earth would I say when the speaker asked us about my sexual feelings, and everyone else could talk about them and I couldn’t? (Imagine my relief when, funnily enough, he didn’t ask anyone for any feedback as to their sexual musings!).
The odd thing is that it never occurred to me to question why I didn’t have any sexual feelings. I simply assumed I had them, because we were told that all young people had them. I realised that lots of church people were repressed about sex, so I assumed I was too. I assumed that I must have sexual feelings that were repressed inside of me, and that this is why I didn’t notice them. I assumed they’d come out at some point, and I wondered whether they’d be straight or gay. I remember a couple of well-meaning friends of mine in Canada wanted to help me get a partner. Most of my Canadian friends saw being single as a sad state, and those that were single were sad about it, and those that weren’t tried to relieve me of my sad single state by finding potential boyfriends for me. It had never occurred to me before that I was supposed to be sad about my single state, and I was not very pleased to discover that something I was quite happy with was actually supposed to be a cause for misery. My well-meaning Canadian friends told me that I simply didn’t come across as a sexual being and I had to discover my sexual side by masturbating and watching porn, and then I’d discover a whole new dimension to life. I could think of nothing more dull. I always got bored during sex scenes in movies - why interrupt a perfectly good plot with two people grunting in bed? You might as well interrupt it to show them being constipated on the toilet. So I certainly didn’t want to watch a movie which was just one big long sex scene. And I didn’t want to try masturbation because I didn’t see the point of it and I didn’t want to get smelly hands. They told me to do it in the bath. But why spoil a perfectly lovely relaxing hot bath trying to fiddle with finding my G spot? It would be like trying to solve a difficult mathematical equation in the bath - no chance to relax at all!
I had boyfriends in Canada, thanks to my well-meaning friends, who wanted to save me from a life of miserable singlehood. Most didn’t last long. I broke up with them not because of lack of sexual feelings (I was patient and assumed I had those feelings and I would find them in time) but because I didn’t like the feeling of being attached to someone else. My sense of self got confused and it felt like a confusing burden. One lasted 8 months, as I was very determined that clearly God wanted me to get married (because this is what all Christians do when they grow up, isn’t it?) and here was a nice Christian boy who was as quirky as I was, and it really seemed perfect. I never had sex - I never had any inclination - but I decided I was developing some sexual feelings because I would ask my boyfriend to tickle my hair and my back, and I enjoyed that. However, then I remembered that in primary school I would ask the girl who sat next to me to do the same. It was purely a sensual feeling that I enjoyed, and would make no difference whether it was being carried out by a boyfriend or a machine. This idea quite jolted me - surely, surely, there had to be something different here. I remember saying to my female flatmate ‘I want to try an experiment. Will you sit on the sofa and let me lie with my head on your knee, so I can see if it feels any different with your than it does with my boyfriend.’ She naturally thought it was rather an odd request but was used to my eccentricities, so complied. I tried it, and then declared there was no difference at all, and that clearly the feelings I was getting were no different from feelings of being cosy with a friend.
I remember too in the pharmacies there were these machines that measured your pulse and blood pressure. My pulse is always a bit higher than normal, so I wanted to try an experiment with my boyfriend. ‘I’ll measure my pulse and then do it again with you tickling my back, to see if the relaxation makes it go down’. I tried it, and it did, to my great satisfaction (I like it when my experiments work!). Then I asked my boyfriend to try it. He measured his pulse, and then again with me tickling his back. But rather than making his pulse go down, it made it shoot up. I was most confused at this unexpected disproval of my theory? ‘Why did that happen?’ I demanded. My flat mate, who was with us too, started giggling and said ‘Uh - why do you think?’ And I realised that it was his sexual feelings and I was supposed to have them too, and my pulse should have gone up, not down - and I felt suddenly rather embarrassed that I’d displayed evidence of my lack of sexual feelings to my boyfriend!
Eventually, I broke up with him. I felt bad, because I really enjoyed his friendship, but I realised it was no different from my friendships with anyone else. But I actually didn’t think then that sexual feelings were simply something that I didn’t get. I thought he was simply the wrong man, and that when the right person came, my feelings would emerge from the repressed nooks of my soul.
When I returned to England I set about finding my sexual feelings with more determination. I remember texting my sister asking her to give me ‘masturbation instructions’, which she did with part amusement, part reluctance (of the ‘I can’t believe you’re my sister and we’re talking about such things’ kind). My other sister, being the more prudish type, flat out refused. Well, I followed all the instructions, but nothing happened. I simply found it boring.
I then joined a Christian dating site and went on dates with a variety of men. It started out as a ‘Since unfortunately God wants me to get married, I suppose I’d better go about finding someone’ venture, but soon turned into a ‘Gosh, what a strange man - I’m really curious to see what he’s like and whether he elicits any sexual feelings in me’ thing. No sexual feelings were elicited. Many very strange dates - which I wrote about in entertaining fashion in the online diary I had at the time. I soon collected quite a readership. In particular, one woman who was very scathing about Christians, and loved to mock them. She wanted to talk to me on MSN - she normally never spoke to Christians but she was fascinated to find someone who mocked their own kind.
So we chatted on MSN. I found the conversations fascinating. She asked me lots of direct questions which I answered- I like conversations which involve questions, because then I know what is expected of me. One day she confessed that she’d sometimes been trying to embarrass my Christian sensibilities by asking personal questions about sex. I replied simply that I was never embarrassed, but I was aware that I don’t have anything very interesting to say about it since I don’t get sexual feelings due to being a repressed Christian. The conversation that ensued was very interesting. She told me with amusement that I wasn’t repressed. I told her that, no, really, repression is very common in Christians and I no doubt have it. She told me that I wouldn’t be chatting so openly about sexual things and my lack of sexual feelings if I were repressed, and that I was simply asexual. I had never heard of such a thing, and thought she’d made it up. But upon googling, I discovered that there really are people who don’t get sexual feelngs, and they are called asexuals. And their self-descriptions sounded very like me.
But I wanted to be sure. I would try again with the sexual fantasy thing. I lay on my bed and imagined very hard the feeling of being in bed with a man and having sex. I had no feelings, other than the feeling of being crowded and not wanting to share my bed. Then, to make it equal, and to check in case I was a lesbian, I imagined very hard the feeling of being in bed with a woman and having sex. Again - no sexual feelings. Only the feeling of being crowded and wanting my bed all to myself.
I then researched about asexuality and discovered it’s more common in people on the autistic spectrum, and also in people who are underweight and who get a late menarche (all of which were true for me, although I am no longer underweight). So I decided I could safely say that I was asexual, and surely if there were any sexual feelings inside me I would have at least got a hint of them by now.
As for what it’s like in day-to-day life to be asexual… well, girly chitchat often tends to centre around one’s love life or one’s longing for a love life, and which men are sexy. For someone who finds chitchat difficult anyway, knowing what to say in such conversations is impossible. See, girls tend to assume that other girls fancy boys. If you don’t show any evidence of doing so, they might think you are a lesbian. But asexuality simply isn’t something that occurs to people. And blurting out ‘By the way, I’m asexual, so I don’t relate to any of this’ would be a bit of a conversation killer. It’s not one of those things that it’s easy to slip into the conversation - and even if it was, most people haven’t heard of such a thing and are not really inclined to believe it. And gosh, I can’t tell you how tiresome the old ‘You just haven’t met the right person yet’ line gets! Hmm… yes, I’m 34 years old and I’ve never had a crush or a sexual fantasy or any interest in sexual intimacy at all simply because I ‘haven’t met the right person’. At some point in my life, maybe when I’m 60, the right person will magically materialise and suddenly sexual feelings will appear as by magic inside my body. I don’t think so, somehow.
It would be good if Christian novels included a few characters like me. Or even general novels, come to think of it - I’m not sure when I last read a novel with an asexual character in it. Are we really as rare as all that, or will more of us identify ourselves when it becomes publicly recognised?